During Katie Couric's interview with author of
Hamlet's Blackberry William Powers there
were many points Bill made that struck me as truthful and some points that I
downright disagreed with. First I will go through the points I agreed with.
According to Bill, we as human beings, are missing out on the emotional gaps
and pauses that occur in regular conversation and discussion because of the use
of "screens". I believe that I have fallen victim to this myself on
more than a few occasions. Often times, we are so concerned with answering an
email, or commenting on someone's Facebook picture that we don't take the time
to reflect on what it is that we are actually interacting with; and sometimes,
this impulsive attitude, and lack of pauses can have terrible consequences.
I also agree with his comment and comparison of technology to olden times.
Before there was technology, people relied on information from others in order
to survive, and therefore would act immediately, as the information was
imperative. Because of the way we are wired, we now think that every bit of
information sent our way is essential to our survival and that if it not
checked we are going to suffer; like Powers, I strongly disagree with this
notion.
The second point I agreed with was Powers' on was the mention of being
self-sufficient. As someone who often struggles with being alone, with the
internet access on my phone, I often have an easier time settling for a
technological way of being alone, rather than actually trying to be by myself. Instead
of being content and being by ourselves we don't have to, "we can look at
our tweets all day" and this is something that I think has fueled the
success of technology and these "screens". People who used to feel
alone or never liked being alone, now can avoid that.
The last point I agreed
with was his comparison to Plato’s idea of “distancing oneself”; Plato could
only survive in the city where he was constantly conversing with people.
However, after coming across an issue that he could not speak about in public,
a colleague of his suggested talking a walk to sort out the issue. After
leaving the city, the hustle and bustle, Plato realized that all it took for
him to understand his dilemma was distance. Like Powers I believe that is what
we must do in our day and age. Sometimes is it so easy to accept what we are
told and move on with life. But other times, we must question the information
we are given, and take a step back, distance ourselves from the “screens” and
the information.
One of the main points I disagreed with Powers on, was his
idea that technology is causing communication between families to decrease, and
that technology is causing an interpersonal problem. As a student who attends
university outside of her home state and a 5-hour drive away from home,
technology is what keeps my family closer. Powers talked about a lack of eye
contact between his family and a lack of connection, I negate this by saying
that while my family is mainly connected via “screens” we make sure to spend as
much time together as possible, when we can.
Technology is what allows me to
call my grandmother who lives in Chicago and ask her how her day was going, or
check in on my parents to see how work is. I can FaceTime with my sister and see my dog at home. Thanks to technology I can be in
contact with anyone in my family anytime, anywhere, and for that I am so
grateful.